Repeated Roots of the Characteristic Equation

When the characteristic equation ar² + br + c = 0 has a repeated root r (because b² − 4ac = 0), the equation ay″ + by′ + cy = 0 has only one exponential solution, e^(rx). The second solution is xe^(rx), so the general solution is y = (C₁ + C₂x)e^(rx), with r = −b/(2a).

Before this lesson: Second-Order Homogeneous Linear Equations, Reduction of Order and Complex Roots of the Characteristic Equation

Why a repeated root needs a second solution

A second-order linear equation needs two solutions that are not constant multiples of each other. When the characteristic equation has two different roots, e^(r₁x) and e^(r₂x) do the job. When the discriminant b² − 4ac is 0, both roots are the same number r, and the trial y = e^(rx) gives only one function.

Writing C₁e^(rx) + C₂e^(rx) does not help, because that is just (C₁ + C₂)e^(rx), a single constant times one function. It cannot match two initial conditions in general.

Reduction of order fixes this. Substituting y = ve^(rx) makes every v and v′ term cancel and leaves v″ = 0, so v = x works. The second solution is xe^(rx). The Wronskian of e^(rx) and xe^(rx) is e^(2rx), which is never 0, so the two form a fundamental set.

Repeated roots formula

If ar² + br + c = 0 has the repeated root r, then

y = \left(C_1 + C_2x\right)e^{rx}, \qquad r = -\dfrac{b}{2a}

The repeated root happens exactly when b² = 4ac. Then ar² + br + c is a constant times a perfect square, a(r − r₀)², which is often the fastest way to find the root.

How to solve an equation with a repeated root

  1. Write the characteristic equation ar² + br + c = 0 and check that b² − 4ac = 0.
  2. Find the root r = −b/(2a), or factor the perfect square.
  3. Write y = (C₁ + C₂x)e^(rx).
  4. For an initial-value problem, find y′ with the product rule, then use y(0) and y′(0) to find C₁ and C₂.

Repeated roots examples

Example 1: Factoring a perfect square

Solve y″ + 6y′ + 9y = 0.

r^2 + 6r + 9 = 0

Write the characteristic equation.

6^2 - 4(1)(9) = 36 - 36 = 0

Check the discriminant: it is 0, so the root repeats.

(r + 3)^2 = 0

Factor the perfect square trinomial.

r = -3

Set r + 3 = 0 and subtract 3.

y = \left(C_1 + C_2x\right)e^{-3x}

Use the repeated-root formula.

Answer: y = (C₁ + C₂x)e^(−3x), or y = C₁e^(−3x) + C₂xe^(−3x).

Example 2: A positive repeated root

Solve y″ − 10y′ + 25y = 0.

r^2 - 10r + 25 = 0

Write the characteristic equation.

(-10)^2 - 4(1)(25) = 100 - 100 = 0

Check the discriminant.

r = -\dfrac{-10}{2(1)} = 5

Use r = −b/(2a).

y = \left(C_1 + C_2x\right)e^{5x}

Use the repeated-root formula.

Answer: y = (C₁ + C₂x)e^(5x).

Example 3: An initial-value problem

Solve y″ − 4y′ + 4y = 0 with y(0) = 3 and y′(0) = 4.

(r - 2)^2 = 0 \Rightarrow r = 2

Factor r² − 4r + 4 and solve.

y = \left(C_1 + C_2x\right)e^{2x}

Write the general solution.

y(0) = C_1 = 3

Substitute x = 0; e^0 = 1.

y' = C_2e^{2x} + 2\left(C_1 + C_2x\right)e^{2x}

Differentiate with the product rule.

y'(0) = C_2 + 2C_1 = 4

Substitute x = 0.

C_2 + 6 = 4

Substitute C₁ = 3.

C_2 = -2

Subtract 6 from both sides.

y = \left(3 - 2x\right)e^{2x}

Substitute both constants.

Answer: y = (3 − 2x)e^(2x). Check: y(0) = 3 and y′(0) = −2 + 2(3) = 4.

Example 4: A leading coefficient other than 1

Solve 9y″ + 12y′ + 4y = 0.

9r^2 + 12r + 4 = 0

Write the characteristic equation.

12^2 - 4(9)(4) = 144 - 144 = 0

Check the discriminant.

(3r + 2)^2 = 0

Factor: (3r)² + 2(3r)(2) + 2².

3r + 2 = 0

Take the square root of both sides.

r = -\tfrac{2}{3}

Subtract 2 and divide by 3.

y = \left(C_1 + C_2x\right)e^{-2x/3}

Use the repeated-root formula.

Answer: y = (C₁ + C₂x)e^(−2x/3). The shortcut r = −b/(2a) = −12/18 = −2/3 gives the same root.

Example 5: A critically damped spring (word problem)

A 1 kg mass hangs on a spring with spring constant 16 N/m and damping constant 8 N·s/m, so its position x (in meters, t in seconds) satisfies x″ + 8x′ + 16x = 0. It starts 0.5 m from rest position and is pushed toward rest at 3 m/s, so x(0) = 0.5 and x′(0) = −3. Find x(t), when the mass passes rest position, and how far past rest it goes.

r^2 + 8r + 16 = (r + 4)^2 = 0

Write the characteristic equation and factor.

r = -4

Solve; the root repeats.

x = \left(C_1 + C_2t\right)e^{-4t}

Write the general solution.

C_1 = 0.5

Substitute t = 0 into x.

x' = C_2e^{-4t} - 4\left(C_1 + C_2t\right)e^{-4t}

Differentiate with the product rule.

C_2 - 4(0.5) = -3

Substitute t = 0 into x′.

C_2 = -1

Simplify to C₂ − 2 = −3, then add 2 to both sides.

x = \left(0.5 - t\right)e^{-4t}

Write the motion.

0.5 - t = 0 \Rightarrow t = 0.5

Set x = 0; e^(−4t) is never 0.

x' = e^{-4t}\left[-1 - 4(0.5 - t)\right] = (4t - 3)e^{-4t}

Substitute the constants into x′ and simplify.

4t - 3 = 0 \Rightarrow t = 0.75

Set x′ = 0 to find the farthest point past rest.

x(0.75) = -0.25e^{-3} \approx -0.0124

Substitute t = 0.75 into x.

Answer: x(t) = (0.5 − t)e^(−4t). The mass passes rest position at t = 0.5 s, goes about 0.012 m (1.2 cm) past it at t = 0.75 s, then returns toward rest without crossing again. A critically damped system crosses rest at most once.

Graph of two critically damped motions for t from 0 to 2 seconds, both solving x″ + 8x′ + 16x = 0 and starting at x = 0.5. The solid curve x = (0.5 − t)e^(−4t), pushed toward rest at 3 m/s, drops fast, crosses 0 at t = 0.5, dips to about −0.012 at t = 0.75 and returns to 0. The dashed curve x = (0.5 + 2t)e^(−4t), released from rest, decays to 0 without crossing it.
Both motions have the form (C₁ + C₂t)e^(−4t). Pushed toward rest, the mass crosses once (solid); released from rest, it never crosses (dashed).

Common mistakes

MistakeExample of the errorFix
Using the same exponential twicey = C₁e^(−3x) + C₂e^(−3x)That is one function. The second solution is xe^(−3x).
Multiplying the wrong term by xy = C₁xe^(rx) + C₂x²e^(rx)Only one term gets an x: y = C₁e^(rx) + C₂xe^(rx).
Putting x in the exponenty = C₁e^(rx) + C₂e^(rx²)The x multiplies the exponential: xe^(rx).
Sign error in the root(r + 3)² = 0 so r = 3r + 3 = 0 gives r = −3.
Forgetting the product ruleDerivative of C₂xe^(2x) written as 2C₂xe^(2x)It is C₂e^(2x) + 2C₂xe^(2x).
Not checking the discriminantTreating r² + 6r + 8 as a repeated rootHere b² − 4ac = 4, so the roots −2 and −4 are different.

Related ideas

The three cases of the characteristic equation

Discriminant b² − 4acRootsGeneral solution
PositiveReal and different, r₁ and r₂y = C₁e^(r₁x) + C₂e^(r₂x)
ZeroRepeated, ry = (C₁ + C₂x)e^(rx)
NegativeComplex, α ± βiy = e^(αx)(C₁ cos βx + C₂ sin βx)

The first case is in Second-Order Homogeneous Linear Equations and the third is in Complex Roots of the Characteristic Equation.

Why xe^(rx) works

With a repeated root r, the characteristic polynomial is a(r − r₀)², so b = −2ar₀ and c = ar₀². Substituting y = xe^(r₀x) gives y′ = (1 + r₀x)e^(r₀x) and y″ = (2r₀ + r₀²x)e^(r₀x). Then ay″ + by′ + cy = a(2r₀ + r₀²x − 2r₀ − 2r₀²x + r₀²x)e^(r₀x) = 0.

Roots that repeat more than twice

For higher-order equations, a root r that appears k times gives the solutions e^(rx), xe^(rx), x²e^(rx), up to x^(k−1)e^(rx). For example, y‴ − 6y″ + 12y′ − 8y = 0 has the characteristic equation (r − 2)³ = 0, so y = (C₁ + C₂x + C₃x²)e^(2x).

Critical damping

For a spring mx″ + cx′ + kx = 0, a repeated root happens when c² = 4mk. This is called critical damping: the smallest damping that stops the mass from oscillating. Spring-Mass Systems compares it with underdamped and overdamped motion.

Practice problems

  1. Solve y″ + 2y′ + y = 0.
  2. Solve y″ − 8y′ + 16y = 0.
  3. Solve 4y″ − 4y′ + y = 0.
  4. Solve y″ + 14y′ + 49y = 0.
  5. Solve 16y″ + 24y′ + 9y = 0.
  6. Solve y″ + 4y′ + 4y = 0 with y(0) = 1 and y′(0) = 1.
  7. Solve y″ − 6y′ + 9y = 0 with y(0) = 2 and y′(0) = 5.
  8. Find an equation y″ + by′ + cy = 0 that has the solution y = xe^(5x).
  9. For what values of k does y″ + ky′ + 9y = 0 have a repeated root? Give the general solution for the positive k.
  10. A spring satisfies x″ + 10x′ + 25x = 0 with x(0) = 0 and x′(0) = 2 (x in meters, t in seconds). Find x(t), the time of the largest displacement and that displacement.
Show answers

1.

(r + 1)^2 = 0 \Rightarrow r = -1

Factor r² + 2r + 1 and solve.

Answer: y = (C₁ + C₂x)e^(−x)

2.

(r - 4)^2 = 0 \Rightarrow r = 4

Factor r² − 8r + 16 and solve.

Answer: y = (C₁ + C₂x)e^(4x)

3.

(2r - 1)^2 = 0

Factor 4r² − 4r + 1.

r = \tfrac{1}{2}

Set 2r − 1 = 0, add 1 and divide by 2.

Answer: y = (C₁ + C₂x)e^(x/2)

4.

(r + 7)^2 = 0 \Rightarrow r = -7

Factor r² + 14r + 49 and solve.

Answer: y = (C₁ + C₂x)e^(−7x)

5.

(4r + 3)^2 = 0

Factor 16r² + 24r + 9.

r = -\tfrac{3}{4}

Set 4r + 3 = 0, subtract 3 and divide by 4.

Answer: y = (C₁ + C₂x)e^(−3x/4)

6.

y = \left(C_1 + C_2x\right)e^{-2x},\quad C_1 = 1

The root of (r + 2)² = 0 is −2; substitute x = 0.

y' = C_2e^{-2x} - 2\left(C_1 + C_2x\right)e^{-2x}

Differentiate with the product rule.

C_2 - 2 = 1 \Rightarrow C_2 = 3

Substitute x = 0 and C₁ = 1, then add 2.

Answer: y = (1 + 3x)e^(−2x)

7.

y = \left(C_1 + C_2x\right)e^{3x},\quad C_1 = 2

The root of (r − 3)² = 0 is 3; substitute x = 0.

y' = C_2e^{3x} + 3\left(C_1 + C_2x\right)e^{3x}

Differentiate with the product rule.

C_2 + 6 = 5 \Rightarrow C_2 = -1

Substitute x = 0 and C₁ = 2, then subtract 6.

Answer: y = (2 − x)e^(3x)

8.

(r - 5)^2 = 0

The solution xe^(5x) needs 5 as a repeated root.

r^2 - 10r + 25 = 0

Expand the square.

Answer: y″ − 10y′ + 25y = 0

9.

k^2 - 4(1)(9) = 0

Set the discriminant of r² + kr + 9 equal to 0.

k^2 = 36 \Rightarrow k = \pm 6

Add 36 and take square roots.

(r + 3)^2 = 0 \Rightarrow r = -3

For k = 6, factor r² + 6r + 9.

Answer: k = 6 or k = −6; for k = 6, y = (C₁ + C₂x)e^(−3x)

10.

x = \left(C_1 + C_2t\right)e^{-5t},\quad C_1 = 0

The root of (r + 5)² = 0 is −5; substitute t = 0.

x = C_2te^{-5t},\quad x' = C_2(1 - 5t)e^{-5t}

Drop the C₁ term and differentiate with the product rule.

C_2 = 2

Substitute t = 0 into x′.

1 - 5t = 0 \Rightarrow t = 0.2

Set x′ = 0.

x(0.2) = 2(0.2)e^{-1} = 0.4e^{-1} \approx 0.147

Substitute t = 0.2 into x.

Answer: x(t) = 2te^(−5t); the largest displacement is about 0.147 m at t = 0.2 s

Repeated roots FAQ

What is the solution when the characteristic equation has a repeated root?

If the root r repeats, the general solution is y = (C₁ + C₂x)e^(rx). The extra factor x makes the second solution independent of the first.

Why do you multiply by x for a repeated root?

With only one root, e^(rx) is the only exponential solution. Reduction of order shows that xe^(rx) also solves the equation, and it is not a constant multiple of e^(rx).

How do you know the root is repeated?

Check the discriminant: the root repeats exactly when b² − 4ac = 0. The characteristic polynomial is then a perfect square times a.

What does a repeated root mean for a spring?

It means critical damping. The mass returns to rest as fast as possible without oscillating, and it crosses rest position at most once.

Summary

  • A repeated root happens when b² − 4ac = 0; the root is r = −b/(2a).
  • The general solution is y = (C₁ + C₂x)e^(rx).
  • The second solution xe^(rx) comes from reduction of order.
  • Use the product rule on (C₁ + C₂x)e^(rx) for initial conditions.
  • A root repeated k times gives e^(rx), xe^(rx), up to x^(k−1)e^(rx).

Previous lesson: Complex Roots of the Characteristic Equation

Next lesson: Method of Undetermined Coefficients

Back to the Differential Equations Index